Accept No Substitute for Socialism
Too many progressive politicians are sowing confusion about an important idea.
Socialism is more popular than ever in the United States. According to a new Gallup poll, 43 percent of American adults now view it favorably, the highest rating since the firm started asking in 2010. Among people aged 34 or younger, socialism has majority support with 57 percent. Among Democratic voters, it’s closer to a supermajority at 65 percent. In popularity rankings, Bernie Sanders and Zohran Mamdani are consistently ranked among the most beloved politicians in the country (along with Barack Obama). The Democratic Socialists of America, meanwhile, recently grew to over 130,000 dues-paying members, surpassing the 20th-century Socialist Party of Eugene V. Debs to become the largest such organization in U.S. history. There has, literally, never been a better time to be anti-capitalist in this country.
And yet plenty of politicians and media figures—even those who seem sympathetic to the new socialist wave, and even some who are actual members of DSA—continue to insist that they’re not socialists at all, and that “capitalism” is worth preserving. In elections across the country, we’ve seen this pattern play out over and over, whether it’s congressmembers like Angie Nixon in Florida, Dr. Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, Ro Khanna in California, or mayor-elect Nithya Raman in Los Angeles.
Some appear to be confused about what “socialist” and “capitalist” actually mean, or even to think you can be both at once. Others are misinformed or naive enough to believe that capitalism can be reformed and made “progressive,” and that a fundamental change in the economic system we live under is not needed. But all of them are wrong. And understanding why they’re wrong is important, because there is no substitute for socialist politics. Allowing confusion to fester about the meaning of socialism and capitalism means we will fail to address the fundamental problems causing the worst crises facing humanity.
(It’s also possible that some of these politicians do consider themselves socialists but are afraid to be honest about it, given the controversy surrounding the word, but given the widespread popularity of Sanders and Mamdani, there’s no good reason anymore to shy away from the term.)
The way people talk about socialism in the U.S. can make the issue seem complicated and confusing. There are a lot of reasons for this, including an education system that’s deliberately badly run and full of Cold War-style propaganda. But the concepts are not actually difficult to understand. On its website, DSA spells the core contrast out with clarity:
Capitalism is a system designed by the owning class to exploit the rest of us for their own profit. We must replace it with democratic socialism, a system where ordinary people have a real voice in our workplaces, neighborhoods, and society.
In other words, what you have is a single, fundamental question: who owns and controls the economy? If it’s “the owning class,” meaning private shareholders and business owners, you have capitalism. If it’s “ordinary people,” or the working class, you have socialism. Right now, as you’re probably aware, we live under capitalism in the U.S., and nearly every other country too. Society is divided into classes, the “99 percent” and “1 percent” that Bernie Sanders is always talking about. The vast majority of people must sell their labor to someone else, in order to stay alive, because they don’t own any capital. They aren’t major shareholders or owners in the companies where they work, and don’t have any real decision-making power over their workplaces, because private companies have the structure of dictatorships. These are rigidly hierarchical organizations in which orders are given from the top to those at the bottom, and those at the bottom must obey or leave. People have to take whatever wage they can get, often a small one, and follow whatever directives come down from the corporate office.
But a few people do own capital, and lots of it. This class of people can live off the labor of those who work under them, and they make all the decisions. Thousands of Amazon workers exist on one side of that gap, and Jeff Bezos on the other. Starbucks baristas struggle to improve their working conditions—spending entire shifts on their feet without pause, and breathing harmful substances—while their CEO takes home a salary thousands of times larger than theirs. Socialists want to end this arrangement, eliminate the class divide, and give every worker both decision-making power over their work, and the actual wealth that comes from it.
There are all kinds of complications and sub-genres beyond that (democratic socialism, market socialism, Marxism-Leninism, anarcho-communism, syndicalism, and so on), but that’s the basic gist. Capitalism is a system in which the “means of production” (factories, natural resources, equipment, infrastructure) are privately owned and operated for profit, while socialists believe that production should be done in the interests of society as a whole.
There are promising examples of this kind of socialist system around the world, like in Mondragón, Spain, where 70,000 people operate worker-owned cooperatives, or the landlord-free public housing system in Vienna—or, on this continent, the coffee-growing cooperatives of the Zapatista movement in Mexico’s Chiapas region. The principles themselves are well-established.
But many of our progressive politicians, instead of explaining the problems with a system dominated by rich capitalists and operated for their benefit, still distance themselves from the term “socialism” even as it grows in popularity. For an example, take Angie Nixon. Overall, her campaign in Florida was an inspiring one, and if she’d had a little more support from Chuck Schumer and the institutional Democratic Party, she’d probably be a senator right now. Nixon has already suggested that she’ll run again in 2028, when she might well get across the finish line. That would be an important victory. But when she was asked by a reporter from NBC about why she joined the Democratic Socialists of America, this is what she had to say:
I’m not a socialist. I joined the DSA because I believe in them in regards to fighting for adequate public housing, as well as fighting for quality healthcare, as well as making sure that we are getting our veterans off the street, taking big money out of politics, right?
This is a strange answer, and it gives us a good look at the kind of muddled and contradictory position that’s so common in the U.S., both among politicians and the people who elect them. Nixon identifies some good economic goals: everyone should be housed, everyone should have healthcare, the rich should not buy elections. She identifies DSA as an effective group fighting for those goals. So far, so good. But then, the question remains: with all that being the case, why is she not a socialist?
After all, the main reason those veterans are on the street is capitalists. This is not a country with robust public housing, so most people either pay rent to a private landlord, or a mortgage to a private bank. The “rising cost of housing” is often discussed as if it’s a natural phenomenon, like the weather, but it’s not; it’s the result of individual capitalists making decisions. They have to go in the spreadsheet and type a higher number, and they’ve been doing exactly that until people can’t afford to keep a roof over their heads anymore. They’ve even been caught using price-fixing algorithms to squeeze us all harder. Ditto for healthcare: the reason it can cost between $1,600 and $8,400 to get a brain MRI in the United States is because for-profit companies sell the machines, for-profit insurance companies set the premiums and co-pays, and every step in the process involves profit being siphoned off the top.
As Bernie Sanders is always pointing out, most developed countries have solved this problem by instituting universal healthcare (in some form), bringing the sector under state control (to some extent), and cutting capitalists and profit out. As a result, people in Brazil or Germany do not pay thousands of dollars for MRIs or ambulance rides. But if you leave the capitalists where they are, making all the decisions, how exactly do you expect to make them lower costs? If you want to solve these problems, once and for all, you have to challenge the role of capitalists; you have to take their power over Americans’ economic lives away from them. You need socialism.
For an even more muddled mess of terms and opinions, consider what Los Angeles mayor-elect Nithya Raman told CNN’s Elex Michaelson when she was asked about her relationship to DSA:
I am a capitalist, and I'm also a democratic socialist[...] I want the city to work and when the government is doing its job, it needs to work really effectively, and we need to make sure capitalism works without harm to workers, without worker exploitation, without exploitation of poor people. That's what I'm going to focus on.
Sorry, what? You’re a capitalist and a socialist at the same time? What could you possibly mean by that? Either you can want your city’s economy to be run by private companies and their owners, or you can want it run by workers and their representatives, but you can’t want both things at once. That’s like saying you’re both an atheist and a devout Mormon, or both alive and dead. It doesn’t work like that. Ownership, the legal right to determine what happens to property and to reap the benefits of it, is given to one party or another. If a company is worker-owned or socialized, it is not owned by a capitalist, and vice versa.
As for capitalism working “without worker exploitation,” when has that ever happened, anywhere in world history? The whole economic system began with child laborers in English factories during the Industrial Revolution, and today it still has people making Nike shoes in horrible sweatshops; at no point in between was it ever “without exploitation.” And really, it can’t be. People say socialism is unrealistic, but it’s far more unrealistic to ignore the basic conflict of interests between workers and for-profit employers. Capitalism relentlessly drives employers to exploit workers.
In any company, the boss wants to maximize profit and minimize expense, and your wages and benefits are an expense. Very literally, profit is the share of the revenue that you don’t get, and the Board of Shareholders do. The more generous a company is with pay, benefits, and working conditions, the less profit there will be. The more exploitative it is, the more it can squeeze additional labor from people for the same or less pay, the more it will thrive. This is just math. It’s why Amazon is a trillion-dollar company, and your local artisanal co-op barely breaks even. Amazon doesn’t force delivery drivers to pee in their trucks because its executives are uniquely sadistic, but because money is saved (and the interests of profit are served) when drivers are given punishing schedules. That’s a fundamental feature of capitalism, one you can’t get away from no matter how good your intentions are.
Nixon and Raman are not alone in sowing confusion about what socialism means. In Michigan, there’s Dr. Abdul El-Sayed, who just got elected to the U.S. Senate. His position is at least consistent: he has said, over and over again, that he’s not a socialist at all. This is how he put it during a campaign event in late October:
I’m just not a socialist. You know, I believe in capitalism[...] I think capitalism works well to allocate resources in a market. I think if you look at where we are right now, we don’t live in capitalism. We live in corporatism. Right? Everybody here’s got a phone. Chances are your phone was manufactured by one of two corporations. The carrier’s probably one of three. And so standing up to make sure everybody has free entry and exit into a market is about actually enabling capitalism to work.
Now, in the first place, saying that we “don’t live in capitalism” is ridiculous. Just to emphasize, the economy is controlled by private owners of capital, who make the decisions; that’s capitalism. Since 1991, there have only been small, isolated pockets of non-capitalism anywhere on Earth. Here, it appears El-Sayed is using “corporatism” to mean “a few corporations that dominate any given industry,” the description he’s used in other interviews, and contrasting that against an idealized form of “free-market” capitalism with many competitors. Hence the example about how everybody’s phone, for the most part, is made by either Apple or Samsung. If there were just 50 phone companies, instead of two, or if anyone could start a phone company (“free entry into a market”), the senator-elect seems to think “capitalism” would be perfectly fine.
But it wouldn’t. To think clearly, we must constantly return to the question of ownership. Who decides how resources are allocated? Who decides what is produced and how it is distributed? Socialism is an effort to democratize the economy, to ensure that it is workers who make the decisions and get the benefits. Capitalism serves the owning class. There can be a spectrum between these two poles, but ultimately every dollar of profit flows either to the owner or the worker. And this is true regardless of how many, or how few, competing companies you have within the overall market.
Take El-Sayed’s example. Suppose there really were 50 different phone companies. That might help consumers have more choices of what phone to buy, and it might give manufacturers an incentive to make better and cheaper phones to compete with each other. Nobody ever said capitalism and competition were bad at making electronics. But that doesn’t mean much to the people making the phones. It doesn’t take away the incentive for capitalist bosses to keep their pay low, and keep more of the money flowing upward toward profit. It might even make conditions worse for workers, since cheap labor is an area where one firm can get a competitive advantage over another. In El-Sayed’s ideal capitalism, with greater competition among capitalists, the ruthlessness of that competition can drive more exploitation. Again, the key is not how many companies there are in the economy, but who controls them, and who controls the economy itself.
It also isn’t true that “capitalism works well to allocate resources in a market.” It doesn’t, in fact, do that. It allocates resources shockingly badly, resulting in a glut of pointless consumer products alongside widespread hunger and homelessness. As this magazine pointed out in 2019, you can buy at least ten different varieties of an inflatable pool float shaped like the poop emoji, but not everyone has a bed to sleep in at night, or a meal when they need one. This is not a “good allocation of resources,” and the problem is not a lack of competition. (There is plenty of competition in the market for poop emoji pool floats.) This is the nature of the system, because it weighs the preferences of property-owners over the preferences of the poor.
Capitalism allocates resources badly because if you do not have any money to spend, your preferences do not matter in the marketplace. Whereas the rich capitalist’s preferences do matter, which is why we see the absurdly luxurious, ever-growing mega-mansions that fill the Wall Street Journal’s real estate section each week, while poor people cannot afford housing and healthcare. That is a capitalist system operating perfectly rationally. Perhaps the most disturbing example is climate change. Whether there is one oil company or 50, the profits to be made from selling planet-destroying products are driving us toward apocalyptic disaster.
Over in the House, Representative Ro Khanna has been similarly frustrating. Khanna is often discussed as a possible contender for the presidency in 2028, and he has been one of the loudest advocates for a tax on billionaires’ wealth in California. But like El-Sayed, he is always clear that he is not a socialist. He says that he’s friendly with democratic socialists, including serving as a co-chair for Bernie Sanders’ presidential campaign in 2020, but only because he believes “democratic socialism does not mean that you’re going to seize the means of production.” In fact, his goal is to prevent them from being seized. Comparing himself to FDR, he explicitly calls his desired wealth tax an “anti-revolution tax,” and says it should be useful to stop “a total tearing-down of the economic system” and “to save capitalism from itself.”
Now, if you really want to split hairs, Khanna is right about “seizing the means of production,” because the word “seize” implies force, and the “democratic” in democratic socialism implies that the transfer can be accomplished peacefully, by means of elections. But the core point is that there must be such a transfer of economic power. If you don’t have one, the most you can ever do is make reforms around the edges of capitalism, while leaving the central problem—the class divide—in place. You can treat symptoms, but never the disease.
This was true of FDR himself, who made some meaningful reforms—the Social Security system, the federal minimum wage—only for the New Deal to be slowly dismantled over the following decades, as capitalists reasserted their dominance. They weren’t conclusively defeated, so they just came back. Right now, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent is contemplating how to use “Trump Accounts” as a “back door for privatizing Social Security,” demolishing what FDR built. Trying to “save capitalism” was ultimately a misguided mission, and even more so for us today.
Even those whose job it is to help people understand politics can contribute to confusion here. Podcaster and author Jennifer Welch, of the I’ve Had It podcast, has solidly progressive politics, and her book Not Today, Fascists is worth reading. But when she sat down for an interview with Current Affairs, she was reluctant to embrace “democratic socialism” as a political position:
Whenever you have to make a point, then you have to explain, “Well, it's not really socialism; it's democratic socialism, and what that means is you have capitalism, and you have this with it.” Whenever you have to explain what your answer is, versus saying, “I want regulated capitalism; I don't want these corporations to have this much power,” it messages better in places where I come from.[...] What is democratic socialism? It is very regulated capitalism with a strong social safety net for the population. And so if I had my choice when I'm pitching it to people, I wish I didn't have to use the word “socialism.”
But democratic socialism is not simply “very regulated capitalism with a strong safety net.” This is an easy thing to confuse, because “democratic socialism” sounds a lot like “social democracy,” which does roughly match Welch’s description. A lot of socialists, like streamer Hasan Piker, even think “modest, nominal social democracy in America” is a desirable first step, leading to socialism in the long term. But democratic socialism is socialism, meaning that, again, capitalists and profit have been removed from the equation. These are critical distinctions to keep straight, because although social democracy would be an improvement over the rampant, no-holds-barred capitalism we see at the moment, it also isn’t enough. And it’s not enough because it leaves in place the fundamental divide between the owners of capital, and the working class who are exploited.
There remain questions as to how socialist institutions should operate, and difficult cases. For example: a hospital run by its doctors and nurses might not have a division between workers and owners, but it might still gouge patients. An oil company could be run as a worker cooperative and still destroy the planet. Whether there can be a “market” under socialism is a subject of debate among those who call themselves socialists. Many socialists aspire to a full decommodified society. Others (Burgis, Sunkara, and Beggs, for example) think you could have an economy that gets rid of capitalists but still has monetary exchange and profit-seeking firms (i.e. worker cooperatives). But the crucial thing is that every vision of a socialist economy has to eliminate the divide between labor and capital. While there is debate about how socialist institutions should work, there is no confusion about the underlying values of socialism.
We know what a socialist institution looks like. Take healthcare. You can have a socialized healthcare system within an otherwise-capitalist country. And what does that mean? It means that money does not flow through for-profit corporations owned by capitalists. You can socialize insurance alone, leaving capitalist healthcare institutions with a government payer (for-profit ambulances but Medicare pays the bills). Or you can socialize the whole system (the ambulances, hospitals, clinics become government services like the fire department or the library). In one system, the institution is ultimately set up for the benefit of the capitalist owner, with the patient benefitting only to the extent that their interests can be made to coincide with those of the owners. For example, if producing a cure for a disease is profitable, the patient may be able to have their disease cured. But the capitalist will ask questions like: “Is curing patients a sustainable business model?”
Or take travel. In the U.S., airlines are jacking up fares because the profit-maximizing corporations that run them prefer “yield” over “load factor,” which is earnings-call jargon meaning “the amount of money you can squeeze out of travelers is more important than how many people get to travel.” If the plane is half-empty but tickets cost three times as much, the airline might do better than a full plane with cheaper tickets. If airlines were socialized, run the way many airports are, as a public service, there would be no incentive to maximize “yield.”
There really is no room for ambivalence here. Capitalism, as an economic and political system, is totally unacceptable, and it has to end. In part, this is a moral imperative, because no system devised by human beings has ever caused more unjust suffering—from child labor, to chattel slavery and the cotton industry in the U.S. South, to British traders flooding China with opium, to the people slaving away in cobalt mines right now to build iPhones.
But even if you discount the moral dimension, the end of capitalism is also a practical imperative, because there is no practical way for it to continue without disaster on a planetary scale. If left unchecked, capitalism will destroy the human species in the name of profit, whether by roasting the planet in fossil-fuel emissions, fomenting a war for the benefit of the arms industry that turns nuclear, or loosening health and safety standards until it spreads a pandemic that makes COVID-19 and Ebola look cuddly. These are not abstract hypotheticals. The top capitalists in the U.S. and Europe are now openly discussing human extinction as a possibility, and they have concluded they’d rather risk terminating our whole species than give up their profits. That isn’t a system that can be allowed to continue any further.
The socialist movement in the United States is only now beginning to regain the size and strength it had in the early 20th century, the era of Eugene V. Debs. We are rebuilding, brick by brick, after decades of Red Scare suppression and propaganda. There isn’t always a socialist politician available to support in any given election. There will be moments where it makes sense to align with a social democrat, a “progressive,” or even a liberal to accomplish a specific goal. But we must never lose sight of the bigger truth: that as Debs put it, “We have been cursed with the reign of gold long enough.” Only a politics that aims to end that reign for good is adequate to our moment, and in the long run, only socialism will do.
