David Griscom, author of “The Myth of Red Texas,” unpacks the election results that shocked America.
Skopic
Well, this seems like a common theme with these blue wave elections. It seems like after the 2024 result, when Trump became the first Republican to win the popular vote in years and years and made these inroads with Black and Hispanic voters, the Republicans really got high on their own supply. They decided that they could just push the most extreme candidates, and voters would eat it up. There was Victor Marx who ran for governor of Colorado, and Vivek [Ramaswamy] in Ohio. There’s also Ken Paxton, who, if not for Trump, might be the most corrupt man in America. I wonder how you weigh the terribleness of the Republicans and how they have self-destructed, versus the strength of the Democrats’ new, more populist approach.
Griscom
Yes, and this is a little bit of a both-sides answer, but I think it’s a bit of both. The Republicans fumbled the ball, but we picked it up and ran it into the end zone. You know what I mean? Certainly, they made a huge mistake here. But this had been going on for a long while. You look at a lot of things that have happened in Texas in recent years, like the abortion ban, for example. You look at opinion polling; it’s not very popular. Abortion in Texas is one of those things that’s a major issue for sure, and maybe the opinions in Texas are different from California or New York, but they certainly aren’t what was being put forward by the Republican Party of Texas. Similar things with gun laws in this state. And another great example is the school voucher program, which Greg Abbott basically forced through the state. Tim Dunn, a billionaire, shot a money cannon at any Republican who was going to break from that. Traditionally, rural Republicans were very against school vouchers because schools are very important in rural America, as a civic place and as an economic engine, so they basically put forward anybody—I don’t want to call Republicans moderate, but anybody who just wasn’t willing to toe the party line. They basically eradicated all those folks from the party. Extremely unpopular.
You’ve got the Big Bend wall. Big Bend, for people who don’t know, if you’re a Texan, this is a very important part of our national or state identity to have this place, and they were going to bulldoze it over so that Donald Trump could enrich a few of his friends. Something that even Republicans who are hardline on the border didn’t really want. In fact, even Brandon Herrera opposed the Big Bend border wall, surprisingly enough. So there had been all of this type of stuff. Adding to that, as this election became clear and clearer that it was going to be close, the fact that Paxton doesn’t debate Talarico, and the fact that Greg Abbott didn’t debate Gina Hinojosa, just showed a complete arrogance and a lack of interest in even doing the basics of political campaigning. Paxton’s the worst with this. Paxton barely campaigned. It was really wild.
I wouldn’t necessarily consider Ted Cruz to be a very charismatic campaigner or a real shoe leather politician, but frankly—I’d have to look at the numbers, but it seemed like [Cruz had] more events and more media spots than Ken Paxton toward the very end. Ken Paxton could barely stay in the country. He, of course, spent July 4 in jolly old England and was also caught watching fireworks in Dubai—the Attorney General of the state of Texas, in Dubai—with a literal fugitive of justice, somebody who defrauded our healthcare system for millions and millions of dollars. Ken Paxton was standing next to him, watching fireworks. It just doesn’t get as naked as that kind of corruption, and the lack of interest in everyday folks.
Paxton really, I think, represented two things. Certainly, how out of touch Republicans have gotten with everyday folks, but also the control that the far-right wing of the party has enjoyed for so long. The Republican Party has been very powerful in Texas for a long time, and that has allowed a smaller and smaller group to have outsized influence over our society and our politics. And I think it really shows just how undemocratic the Republican Party had gotten when you saw somebody like Ken Paxton win the nomination. Another figure, Don Huffines, a super far-right Texas politician, actually ran against Greg Abbott back in 2022 to his right. He got appointed to be Texas comptroller, and he lost to Sarah Eckhardt in this election. And he said something that I thought was pretty interesting. One, he thinks it’s going to be almost impossible for Republicans to win the state back. Well, I hope that’s the case. And two, he blamed the leadership. This is a flag bearer of that even more far-right part of the Republican Party. And so there’s certainly going to be a big war and a lot of finger-pointing going on between folks over the next few months.
Skopic
This is one of the things I wonder about too: how durable will this end up being? In 2020 there was a pretty big, though not as big as this, blue wave election where Trump was thrown out as president. Georgia went blue for the first time in a while. Raphael Warnock got in, and that was treated at the time as, “Well, this is the end of Trumpism.” As it turns out, not so much. And now we’re hearing again that this could be the end of Trumpism. I wonder, do you expect that in 2028, Texas will go blue presidentially? Is this going to be something that lasts for a decade, or is this maybe a one-and-done? And what does it depend on?
Griscom
This is a major fear of mine, obviously. That we do this, and then it just goes back. Obviously, that’s the nightmare scenario. I think that in a lot of ways—and look, I hope I’m right about this. I could be wrong. I have felt Trump had been done before. This does feel like a fundamental shift away from Trumpism. That doesn’t mean, by the way, that it’s an end to the right or even the far right, but whatever this brand is, built around Trump and loyalty to Trump, feels like that has been weakened tremendously. This election and this sweep of Democrats was so huge, and while I have a lot of kind things to say about Gina Hinojosa in particular and James Talarico as well, a lot of people got swept up, and millions of Texans said just “no” to the Republican Party.
But that also means there are a lot of folks who will be in positions of power who might not have internalized the lessons as to why the Democratic Party had failed in this state for so long, and may not be willing to do the things that are necessary. In the Texas legislature, and a tremendous amount of respect for her, but they’ve selected an 87-year-old woman, [Senfronia Thompson], to be the speaker of the Texas House. If you’ve seen anything about problems with the Democratic Party, that’s kind of worrying to me. Now, again, folks who I know say that she basically was the only consensus candidate. This was the one that they needed to not have a very rambunctious, let’s say, contest over the speakership. But it makes me nervous.
I think one thing to watch, one thing I’m watching really closely, is how effective Gina can be in a divided government, because the Democrats do not control the Senate. There’s also the question of gambling. They have been wanting to legalize gambling in the state of Texas forever, and lobbyists have dropped a lot of money on Texas politicians, both on the Democrat and the Republican side, for years, including very famously James Talarico. While he was a member of the Texas legislature, he got $59,000, I believe, from Sands PAC, which Miriam Adelson is a major donor to. That’s going to be a live question, and it’s going to be really tempting to Texas Democrats because we don’t have a state income tax, and there are a lot of limits on ways for the government to raise revenue. So I think a lot of them are very tantalized by the idea of being able to use gambling to kind of fund the government. But that would be an absolute disaster, because what is gambling? Gambling is a war on the poor. It’s a war on the desperate. If you get addicted to gambling to fund your schools, to fund your system of government, you are condemning everybody in your state to live with this horror, this family-destroying industry here. And I really, really hope that those Texas Democrats don’t get called by the siren song.
Vikki Goodwin, who’s going to be lieutenant governor, said something along the lines of being ambivalent on the question. “It’ll be up to Texas.” I would like just a straight-up “no” from these folks. So that’s going to be something that I’m watching, because really I think that shows the difference between populism and an old-school liberalism. Liberals are very afraid of saying no, of saying something should be illegal, even if it’s extremely damaging. As a socialist, I think we have a moral and social and communal responsibility to one another to not allow corporations to come and ruin people’s lives. So that’s something I’m going to be watching really closely to see how serious these things go. And to answer your question about whether Texas in 2028 could go blue, I think there’s probably no way to look at what happened in this recent election and not say that Texas is very likely to be on the board in ’28. The real question will be: Are Democrats able to take advantage of this historic opportunity to show that there is an alternative out there, that people’s lives can get better? What is my responsibility? What is your responsibility if you’re a Texan listening to this? Make sure that they take advantage of this moment to demand that they do. What we saw was a tremendous willingness from Texans to buck tradition and to buck the political parties that have been in power. I don’t think that any of them will be very quick to give up that power if they’re unsatisfied with what government looks like in the state of Texas.
Skopic
Yes, and I think this is the story of the whole country right now: there’s a real crisis of legitimacy for both parties. People have caught on that neither party necessarily has their best interests in mind. With the gambling issue, especially, we’ve been through close to a decade now of this push for it to be legalized. And you’re exactly right, it’s always been framed in these liberal terms about personal choice and economic opportunity. Even socialists, I think some of them, are very scared for historic reasons of being called authoritarian. But I think there are cases, and gambling is a perfect example, where some authority needs to be brought to bear. And I don’t know if you followed what just came out of Brazil, but Lula just got reelected and banned online betting across the whole country. I think the statistics are that pretty much immediately when he did that, spending on food increased by 6 percent, just because the grocery money isn’t going to the gambling.
Griscom
Yes, absolutely. And it’s like, look, if you’re a socialist, you understand markets. The idea has always been to bring these industries out of the shadow and into the light. But when you create a market, a market is going to try to sell those products. They’re going to try to push those products. And if you legalize something, it is going to grease the wheels of the market. It is going to make these things more accessible. It is going to make them easier, and yes, more and more people will utilize this because they have easier access to it. And I think that certainly in Texas, but also across the board on the left, we need to be very comfortable talking about the problems with expanding markets. I think that this is a fundamental value. Return to tradition, my friends, on issues like this. I think Lula really is showing the way.
Skopic
And the other thing, of course, is that with all of these races, it’s exactly right that everything will depend on what Democrats can actually deliver with these seats they’ve won. And so, on the gambling issue, and there are a few others, I wonder how much you think Democrats, now that they have control of Texas, will be able to do. On the border issue, Gina Hinojosa is a massive contrast to Greg Abbott, who was just purely sadistic about the border. He put circular saw blades in the Rio Grande.
Griscom
Yes.
Skopic
So with this divided legislature, with Democrats having a mandate from the voters but not full control over the government, where do you see the border going?
Griscom
Because of how much power has been concentrated in the executive branch of Texas, Gina is going to have a lot of opportunity to roll things back. What you’re just talking about there, Alex, was an executive order from Greg Abbott. Greg Abbott issued an emergency declaration, which gives him more and more power. So obviously, getting somebody like Gina into that position is going to open up opportunities to pull back a lot of that. I think no longer cooperating with ICE is going to be a major demand. Look, I’m as pessimistic about Democrats as any good socialist is or should be, but they do have an advantage here, and that advantage is that the Republican Party has wielded power for so long. Think about all the cases that Ken Paxton, as Attorney General, has been engaged in that are no longer going to be run out of the Attorney General’s office. That’s a massive victory. That means no more coming after providers for mailing abortion pills or things of that nature. All that can just go away on day one.
One of the points I made in my book is that, yes, Texas had these Republican supermajorities in the state government, but Austin’s been a liberal city my entire life. San Antonio—all these major cities are pretty much run by Democrats and very often by progressives. In Austin, we’ve been trying to build a train system forever. You know how hard that is to do? You know how difficult that is in a state like California? Imagine trying to do that when you have a state government that is passing laws and trying to prevent you from being able to break ground on those projects. Just in the past week there’s been talk of expanding the train plans that we had, because we no longer have this kind of opposition. So Democrats are going into a situation where, yes, they don’t have full control of the government, but they have a lot of advantages just in the absence of a hostile state government. In a state where progressive power has for the most part lived at the city and local level, those areas are really going to be able to deliver, even if the state government kind of gets stuck.
Skopic
The ICE issue is especially interesting, because we’ve seen these conflicts about ICE in cities all over the U.S., where blue governments get in, and then Trump and Stephen Miller, who now is his chief of staff, decide they’re going to throw their weight around. They’re going to basically invade. We had it here in New Orleans. They had it in Minneapolis. New York, to an extent, has been able to avoid it because Mamdani is so good at charming Trump.
Griscom
Yes.
Skopic
But do you expect to see that kind of thing if the reforms happen?
Griscom
We’ll see. Look, an interesting one is John Whitmire, the mayor of Houston, who is ostensibly a Democrat, but fairly right-wing. He announced that they’re going to pull back their cooperation with ICE, and that’s a huge victory. That’s one of the largest cities in the country. Absolutely massive. Also, a city where a man was shot by rogue ICE agents. So this will be a massive shift. Look, I think we’re all watching this with tremendous excitement, but also a sinking realization that they’re going to try a lot. The fact that so many people are getting off the Trump ship on the federal level is certainly a good thing. It shows the weakness of Trump. But now the elevation of somebody like Stephen Miller means they are absolutely going to try to do everything that they can to wage war and punish the American people. So the only thing that’s going to be able to beat that is continuing the mobilization and the energy that bucked the Republicans in the first place. I think there’s going to be a lot of controversy. I think there’s probably going to be some really ugly episodes over the next two years, but hopefully that only bolsters people’s commitment to never allow something like this to happen again.
Skopic
Well, we certainly hope so. Just here in New Orleans, having so many ICE troops on the street was not fun. And the other issue that’s in a similar vein, where I wonder what hand the feds may decide to play, is on abortion. When Dobbs happened in ’22, Texas, along with a few other southern states, was one of the first to immediately do an abortion ban. And along with Louisiana, in the South, it’s been the site of some of the ugliest incidents of people being prosecuted for having a miscarriage, and people being tracked by the cops when they try to go to another state to have an abortion. How much of that do you think the new blue government will be able to roll back, and how much pushback from the federal level do you expect?
Griscom
There are people who probably understand the kind of intricacies of the legislature more than I do to come up with a strategy. I think that there’s certainly going to be an attempt to repeal these laws that have been passed, but one immediate thing, as I said before, is that we now have a Democrat attorney general. He’s no longer going to be pursuing this issue. Ken Paxton really was wildly expanding the role of the Attorney General in maliciously prosecuting individuals, coming after doctors—all these kinds of threats. That is going to go by the wayside. So that power has gone away. The question about whether we’re going to be able to have the procedure legalized here—I think it probably feels like it might not be possible until ’28. But again, look, if you’re one of these Republicans in the Senate, and you saw what just happened, I don’t want to sit here and predict that they’re going to flip necessarily, but I think that there is a little bit of opportunity to pressure folks to move on things, and we’ll see.
One thing that has been frustrating[...] is that they are bringing some Republicans into these transition teams. I don’t like that personally for many reasons. First, millions of Texans just said, to quote our friend in Indiana who ran for that county position, “I want to fire every Republican.” That was really the mood of so many Texans in this election. I don’t like [the bipartisanship] that much, but look, maybe I’m too harsh, and maybe it ends up being this symbolic thing that makes people happy. I know it’s the kind of thing that people do like, because they’re just thinking, “Oh wow, we’re all coming together, and we’re getting past partisanship.” Again, I have my doubts. Maybe I could be wrong. Maybe it’s just a gimmick. And historically, populism has always had a lot of gimmicks in government.
I’m not so worried that they’re going to try to govern as Republicans, but man, the last legislative session, Alex—traditionally in Texas, you have always given committee appointments to the opposition party, which has just been a part of Texas political tradition for a long while. Republicans tried to basically stop that practice in the most recent session. There is a kind of irony to immediately inviting those people back into the positions of influence after all of this. I think right now, the way people, Texas politicians, Texas Democrats, and just independents across the board should be thinking about Republicans is we want to invite Republican voters and people who consider themselves Republicans into the movement, but I just don’t think that you should be inviting these traitors into positions of power at this point.
Skopic
No, I totally agree on that. This is something that always frustrates me about liberals and Democrats. Kamala Harris said she would have a Republican in her cabinet. Barack Obama recently said, once again, what he always says: that we need a strong Republican Party.
Griscom
No, we don’t. We don’t. One thing that I thought James Talarico did that was so good with “it’s not left versus right; it’s top versus bottom” is that it gives people who are Republicans the excuse and the permission to break [away]. I think that kind of rhetoric is viable, and I think it’s useful. I don’t think that you need to reward politicians who have been fighting against everything that we’ve been supporting for years and years. So again, maybe this is just a little bit of symbolism. I think that people are probably very tired of the way that politics has entered into every aspect of your life, the divisions in families, and things like that. Which, as we know, we don’t like Republicans, but we have our criticisms of Democrats too. A lot of those divisions, at least among working people, are fairly artificial. A lot of times, your political party is just a kind of extension of your regional identity. So giving people the opportunity to come over and participate in this thing is good. But they wanted to restrict democracy, my friends. You know what I mean? We need to be serious about the threat. It is funny. I can’t cite anybody in particular, but I talked to multiple of these state-elected officials, both on and off the record. And a frequent concern that people had was that the Republicans would just deny election results, and that was my feeling too. Again, it was so big that they couldn’t do it. But man, if you thought they were going to do that a few years ago, I think bringing them back into power could be disastrous.
Skopic
Yes, I think in the next few years this is one of the biggest worries that I also have, because we have a history in America with this problem. After the Confederacy was crushed, we allowed a lot of the leaders to go off and still have positions of influence in various places. And after the Nazis were beaten, we invited a lot of them over to help us run NASA. And the MAGA movement—what they’re up to five or 10 years down the line is concerning. Democrats have this idea of the “team of rivals,” and it comes from Lincoln and his cabinet, and I always want to ask them, well, how did that end for him? What happened to him?
Griscom
Well, again, their strategic weakness is to our benefit, and that’s why I’m just so optimistic right now. I’m so happy. That’s why you can’t wipe this smirk off my face, because it’s just like the political doors have swung wide open. Almost 20 percent of Texans who voted in these most recent elections said that they were democratic socialists. That’s huge. That’s massive. At the height of Texas socialism, they were getting 12 to 15 percent of the vote, which was historically notable and massive. But we’re at a moment right now where, yes, it’s a little bit vaguer. We don’t have the same level of party organization that we did back then, but we’re here. We’re here right now. That’s what I’m telling the editors across the state of Texas right now: “Y’all need to publish me, because I’m no longer a representative of a fringe esoteric movement; it’s actually becoming more and more mainstream and influential.” And we need to take advantage of this opportunity, certainly the weakness of the Republican Party, but also the strategic mistakes of the Democrats. The door is wide open.
Some people have accused me of libbing out too much, and getting too close to Democrats after this election. But I can’t look around and just lie and say that this isn’t a massive shift, and this isn’t a massive opportunity for our kind of politics. We are going to demand a seat at the table, and if these folks who have been elevated make mistakes, and break, and betray the trust of the voters, we need to be right there to be the recipient of the backlash instead of allowing that to go to the right. So that’s why I’m very happy to engage in conversations with a lot of different folks right now and genuinely—genuinely—advocate and fight for these officials in the Democratic Party who I might disagree with to do the best that they can, to not sabotage, to actually try to make sure that things that were promised are delivered. But also to be here and say, “We are the force that is fighting for the things that people want.” So if they make promises that they don’t meet, there is a force in politics in Texas that has been there from the get-go as a friendly partner when they’re trying to build, and as a strong critic when they don’t, and this is a massive opportunity for us.
Skopic
Absolutely, and this is a project that we’re engaged in also. We are here on the bayou, and for a long, long time, leftists in the South have been ignored, and the South as a whole has been ignored, because all the media is in D.C. and New York. And now, finally, as the great OutKast said, the South has something to say. And you have been at the forefront of this. You wrote the book. And as we start to wrap up here, to the people who are now tuning in for the first time, to the national publications, and to the national audience: what do they need to know about Texas that they don’t yet know?
Griscom
Look, I went on this book tour across the state of Texas, and this book, thankfully, has been fairly successful for a lefty book from a small press. But we were shut out of the mainstream media, and so a lot of people were shocked by this [result]. But frankly, I really wasn’t, man. I went across Texas, and at every event that we did in the great state, we sold out of books. We had hundreds of people showing up in little bookstores all the way from Dallas to Brownsville. And I’m not saying this to pat myself on the back, but just to say, there is such an appetite and a hunger for a different kind of politics here. Frankly, a lot of people are just saying, “Man, I’ve always felt this way, but I’ve never felt like I had the right or the ability to advocate or to be public and open about these things.” And we’re not going back into the shadows. We’re not going back into our bunker right now, and people are going to have to deal with the fact that Texas is a blue state now and that is very much a Texan thing.
If I could just say really quickly, Alex, one thing that you’ve seen from a lot of folks is the story of transplants. “Oh my lord, all these transplants from California came to Texas, and that’s what flipped it blue.” Nothing could be further from the truth. Just think about the two most famous transplants from California to Texas: Joe Rogan and Elon Musk. And guess what party they’ve been supporting? If anything, a lot of these California voters have been making Texas redder over the past few years. People have been self-selecting. People have been moving to Texas because it’s run by Republicans. The margins and the sweeping nature of this victory were just so massive that it meant that millions and millions and millions of Texans showed up. And I’m not saying this to disparage anyone, or to not invite our new friends and neighbors into our kind of politics, but I think it’s really important that we push back against this narrative that Texans were “replaced.” That other people have kind of come in. No, no. This is a homegrown tradition.
In 2018, had the right to vote been restricted only to native-born Texans, not something I would support, but just a fact, Beto O’Rourke would have won the election. And I think that as Texans, we need to be a little bit more confident and push back on this myth of red Texas. That to be a Texan means being on the right—we saw overwhelmingly that that’s no longer the case. And I will just say, as a little bit of hope, maybe if I have had any magic or influence on these results, the next book I’m working on right now will be a big book about the South, talking about these forgotten traditions across the South. So hopefully we can spread the good cheer, and build up this left-wing working-class movement across this part of the country.
Transcript edited by Patrick Farnsworth.
