A Magazine of Politics and Culture

Mamdani’s “Richard Scarry Socialism” Can Make City Life Simple Again

The NYC mayor is trying to build a city that functions like a city in a children's picture book, where people aren’t caught in a web of lies and scams.

There are no memecoins in Busytown. There is no gig economy. There are no junk fees, phishing scams, fine print, higher than normal call volume, deepfakes of Bill Gates hawking fake Alzheimer’s cures, sponsored search results, phony reviews, dynamic pricing. There are no collateralized debt obligations, credit default swaps. The people of Busytown are not followed by an all-seeing Palantir eye that compiles a data profile on them. Private equity has not bought their apartment buildings. There is no slopaganda in Busytown. In Busytown, life is straightforward and things are what they seem to be.

Sometimes I open my copy of Richard Scarry’s classic children’s book Busy, Busy Town just to remind myself how the world ought to function. One of over 300 books Scarry published, Busy, Busy Town is about the world of work, depicting all of the animals going about their jobs. Everything is refreshingly straightforward. At the garage, “when something is wrong with the motor, the mechanic fixes it.” The painter paints the walls. “On Main Street you can buy medicine, tools, apples, and oranges.” When there is a pothole, workers from the city come and fill it.

 

Of course!

 

Economists and politicians often scratch their heads wondering why people are unsatisfied with the economy even when, by conventional criteria, it is “doing well.” I suspect one reason is that the 21st century U.S. economy is just a difficult system for ordinary people to survive in, in part because so many things are more complicated than they ought to be. Compare, for instance, the experience of American healthcare today to the world of Busytown. I’ve written before about how maddening the experience of trying to comparison shop for insurance policies on Healthcare.gov can be. (The New York Times quoted an economist who found the system so complicated that they gave up trying to compare the plans.) I’ve also written about how sponsored search results have made people fall for insurance scams. That’s just buying health insurance, of course. Using it is a whole other matter, and when we think about people who have spent time dealing with complicated medical billing during a loved one’s fatal illness, we understand a bit better why so many people cheered when Luigi Mangione shot the CEO of UnitedHealthcare. (In his confession, Mangione said that when he had posed as a rich investor to get the details of where the CEO would be, he received the fastest response he had ever had from an insurance company.)

It’s not like this in Busytown. When Lowly the worm goes to the medical center, Nurse Nelly, Dr. Lion, Dr. Rabbit, and Dr. Dentist simply take care of him, then he leaves. (Sidenote: why is Dr. Dentist not called Dr. Fox? The inconsistency is grating to me.) And as Current Affairs has noted many times before, it is possible for us to have this kind of system in our world. This is not a children’s book fantasy. You really can have a system where people’s first thought when they call an ambulance is not “How am I going to pay for this?” Dr. Abdul El-Sayed, a leading proponent of Medicare For All, says providing free-at-point-of-use universal healthcare is not only possible, but is necessary because “it shouldn’t be this hard” to attain basic things like being treated for an illness.

 

 

Which brings me to Zohran Mamdani. Now, I know I risk getting a reputation as someone forever coining bizarre types of idiosyncratic “socialisms,” having already written about Mamdani as a “suit socialist.” Marxist purists will assuredly roll their eyes when I introduce another attempted coinage, Richard Scarry socialism, to describe part of what I think Mamdani is trying to do. But I think there is an important way in which Mamdani’s approach to being the mayor of New York has not just been about trying to create a fairer city, but a city that operates a little more like a city in a children’s picture book might operate. The mayor’s celebration of garbage workers and taxi drivers, his promise to simplify city bureaucracy, his promotion of parks and operas and ticker tape parades—I’ve seen more than one person online say that Mamdani seems like a mayor from a 1990s kids’ movie. I can’t remember enough 1990s kids’ movies to know if that’s true, but I do think he seems like he’s trying to be the mayor of Busytown. Sometimes I’m surprised he doesn’t walk around wearing a big sash that says MAYOR on it.

It’s all so damned wholesome. I just looked at his social media and today he announced a scavenger hunt to teach people about labor history. But I think there’s something clever about focusing on things like making subscriptions easier to cancel and making sure the salary you’re owed is the salary you’re paid. It’s not just that wage theft is unjust and should be prosecuted, which is true. But stopping it also makes the world a little less full of lies and fraud. The “Trump era” is basically built on fraudulence. Scams are everywhere. People are constantly trying to rip you off and take your money, and it is exhausting just trying to know what’s true. Grandparents get scam calls from deepfakes of their grandkids saying they want money, for God’s sake. I think this is one reason people are so suspicious of AI. Defenders of data centers argue that the negative reaction to them overstates their water and electricity use. But I think people’s objections to data centers go beyond the noise they make and the electricity they use; they associate data centers with the move toward a world in which everything is more confusing and our lives are governed by forces we cannot understand or control. AI is a horrible escalation of our drift into a world where we are just constantly being lied to and manipulated by people who want to squeeze a profit out of us. (Including the president of the United States himself, who wants to sell you a memecoin and an NFT!)

Not everything about the Mamdani administration is sunny and cheerful and ideal. I am certainly critical of his decision to allow the NYPD to arrest anti-Netanyahu protesters, and his battle with labor over bonuses to teachers’ aides, which I think come from a misplaced pragmatism. But one thing I think is hugely successful and important, and that other leftists should copy, is Mamdani’s appeal to people’s nostalgia for “simpler” times. A lot of nostalgia is misplaced, since the past was full of many worse injustices than exist in the present. But it’s true that a gig economy job with an algorithm as your boss is not the same as a Busytown economy in which people still have careers. Look, not everything in Busytown is perfect. (The pigs eat sausages, which is dark, as noted in an article on “animal cannibalism in the world of Richard Scarry.” And as we have noted before, there appear to be subtle class divisions, with pigs doing a disproportionate amount of the dirty labor.) But when we think about what people want out of life, the “picture book city” is a good place to start. The picture book city is a place of rough equality, where things are what they seem, and where people do things because those things are necessary for society, rather than because they further inflate a capitalist’s stock portfolio. It is an astonishing indictment of our times that the cities of our picture books can seem like a radical utopia. Is it so hard to have a world where ambulance drivers can drive ambulances and the “artists paint pictures”?

 

Screenshot 2026-10-01 at 3.52.08 PM

 

Screenshot 2026-10-01 at 4.25.01 PM

 

 

More In: Editor’s Notes

Cover of latest issue of print magazine

Announcing Our Newest Issue

Featuring

an investigation into the Department of (In)justice, a deep-dive into Milton Friedman’s neoliberal hellscape, and a journey with America’s modern-day train-hoppers. We revisit forgotten cinema, celebrate Ferdinand the bull’s birthday, and review an unlikely communist-flavored video game. Join us for a road trip down Route 66, then read a firsthand report from the occupied West Bank exposing the horrors of escalating settler violence. Finally, Academy Award-winning filmmaker Adam McKay exposes the climate lie threatening civilization—and Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic nominee for Senate in Michigan, joins us for an exclusive interview.

The Latest From Current Affairs