More than 150 years ago, a group of Irish coal miners called the Molly Maguires were executed in Pennsylvania. Today, the same labor wars continue.
In his own book on American mining unions, historian Harold W. Aurand is blunt about the legitimacy of the Molly Maguire trials: they had none. As he puts it, the whole process was:
[...]one of the most astounding surrenders of sovereignty in American history. A private corporation initiated the investigation through a private detective agency; a private police force arrested the alleged offenders; and coal company attorneys prosecuted them. The state provided only the courtroom and hangman.
In an unprecedented move, Franklin B. Gowen himself served as the chief prosecuting attorney in several of the trials. The judges allowed him to make long, grandiose speeches about the evils of the Molly Maguires, claiming the group was responsible for killing “hundreds of unknown victims whose bones now lie moldering over the face of this county.” In fact, there were only 16 killings in total, some of them with little or no evidence to connect them to an organized group.
For just one example, take the May 1876 trial over the killings of Benjamin Yost, the policeman, and John P. Jones, the mine superintendent. As Kenny writes, five alleged Molly Maguires stood in dock for these crimes: James Carroll, Thomas Duffy, James Roarity, Hugh McGehan, and James Boyle. All of them were Irish Catholics, but no Irish Catholics were allowed on the jury. In fact, Irish jurors were systematically excluded from all of the Molly Maguire trials, so the basic right to a jury of one’s peers was violated from the start. Instead, the jurors were predominantly English, German, and Dutch. Based on his surname, John Cox Sanders could have belonged to any of those groups, but it seems he kept quiet during his particular trial, so very little information about him has survived. The same can’t be said for other jurors. One man, William Becker, reportedly confessed that he “would not understand the witnesses” since he spoke mainly Dutch, while another, Levi Stein, spoke German and “[not] much English.” Both were accepted onto the Yost/Jones jury anyway.
In that case, there was no physical evidence connecting the five accused to the killings whatsoever: no bullet casings, no bloodstains, and no fingerprints (which wouldn’t be used to solve a crime until 1892). Instead, the prosecution’s case hinged entirely on the testimony of James McParland, the Pinkerton spy, and a miner named Jimmy “Powderkeg” Kerrigan, who claimed to be a former Molly Maguire who’d turned state’s evidence. McParland testified that the secret society had an elaborate system of “lodges” throughout northeastern Pennsylvania, one in every mining town, with a ringleader called a “bodymaster” in each lodge and a system of reciprocity between them. When miners in town A had a grievance with their boss, they’d send a message to the Molly Maguire lodge in town B, and killers from there would be dispatched, so nobody in town A would recognize them.
According to Kerrigan, this was how Yost had been killed: Thomas Duffy was the one who actually planned it, as an act of revenge, because Yost had previously arrested and beaten him. But Kerrigan called on Roarity, the “bodymaster” of the lodge in nearby Coaldale. So Roarity sent McGehan and Boyle to actually shoot Yost, while Carroll, a tavern owner, provided shelter and weapons for the visiting assassins. In exchange for their services, McGehan and Boyle later called on some Tamaqua miners to kill John P. Jones, who had blacklisted them.
It was certainly a dramatic story. The problem is, neither McParland nor Kerrigan were remotely trustworthy witnesses. McParland had been hired by the Pinkertons to destroy the labor movement in Pennsylvania, so he had a vested interest in getting convictions, whether or not the people he accused were guilty. Years later, he admitted that he paid at least one witness, a miner pejoratively nicknamed Daniel “The Bum” Kelly, $1,000 to testify against alleged Molly Maguires—a fortune in those days. Meanwhile, Kerrigan freely admitted that he’d been involved in both Yost and Jones’ killing, but pointed the finger at others to save himself. As Kenny writes, “his own wife publicly denounced him as a liar, and testified in court that he had told her he had killed Yost himself.” Apparently, the jury didn’t believe her. All five “Sons of Molly” were convicted of first-degree murder, and all five were publicly hanged in 1877.
The same story would play out, with slight variations, in the rest of the trials: juries where the Irish were systematically excluded, prosecutions run by the coal company, dramatic testimony from McParland and his handpicked witnesses, and swift guilty verdicts. The defense lawyers barely put up a fight, possibly because the impoverished miners couldn’t pay for competent ones. In one case, the jury deliberated for only 20 minutes before handing down the death sentence.
One man, John Kehoe, was tried in 1876 for a murder committed in 1862, and was found guilty despite an eyewitness who said he wasn’t present at the crime scene, mainly because he had called the murdered mine boss a “son of a bitch.” In 1979 Kehoe was issued a posthumous pardon. Altogether, 20 miners were executed that year, ten of them on the same “Black Thursday.” Maybe some of them were guilty; maybe the actual killers walked free, because the prosecution just grabbed whoever it could. At this point, we’ll never know. But none of them got anything resembling a fair trial. The judges failed them, and so did the jurors, my great-great-great-great-grandfather included. It was nothing more than a massacre of rebellious workers by capitalists, with a thin pretense of “law” to cover it. In America, that’s all it takes to put you in the cemetery.
It’s Pennsylvania’s folk music, though, that captures the story in its most evocative form. This was how I first encountered the Molly Maguire legend, before discovering my family’s connection to it: on a thrift-store CD from a local band called Donnybrook, who were themselves covering an older band called the Irish Balladeers. Their song, “Sons of Molly,” is a ghost story:
When the wind blows wild at night
Past the breakers melancholy
If you stand in the dark with your ear to the wind
You can hear the sons of Molly
And deep in the dark of the old mine shaft
You can smell the smoke and fire
And the whispers low in the mine below,
“Tis the ghost of Molly Maguire.”
In each of the next verses, a different ghost speaks, some proudly admitting to a killing (“I come from Carbon County / and I shot the boss of the Lansford mine / now my soul is up for bounty”), and others protesting their innocence (“No pistol did I fire / But I will fall from the gallows tall, just for being a Molly Maguire”). But in either case, you get a profound sense that an injustice was done to them, and because of it, their spirits can’t rest.
There’s even a movie about this period, filmed on location in northeastern Pennsylvania’s coal towns and released in 1970. Simply titled The Molly Maguires, it’s been largely forgotten by cinema critics, but it’s underrated. The director was Martin Ritt, who also made The Spy Who Came in From the Cold and The Great White Hope, and who had been blacklisted from working in television as a suspected communist in 1952. (He’d get his revenge in 1976 with The Front, a savage satire of the blacklist itself starring Woody Allen.) In The Molly Maguires, Ritt takes on the style of an American Ken Loach, capturing the soul-crushing environment of the anthracite mines. Visually, the film is mostly grey and brown, punctuated by occasional eruptions of bright orange flame. It boils down the extended cast of the real Molly Maguire saga into just two totemic figures: Detective McParland, played by Richard Harris, and Sean Connery as John Kehoe, his adversary. On paper, Harris is the protagonist—but the real star is Connery’s Kehoe.
Connery gives a strictly restrained performance, and doesn’t speak his first line of dialogue until about 45 minutes in. As the detective meets and befriends him, he’s still guarded and taciturn—until his mentor, an old retired miner named Mr. Raines, dies of a lung disease in the third act. As the time comes for Raines’ funeral, Kehoe realizes the old man doesn’t even own a suit to be buried in. He finally breaks, and decades of suppressed rage come loose as he talks to his friend’s corpse:
KEHOE: He never made a sound. Forty-two years in the pits, and not even an echo left hanging in the air. Go on, make your sound now, you old bastard! You’re safe among friends. Silence is golden, is that it? Seen but not heard. They beat that lesson into you, didn’t they?
Mad with grief, he storms across the town to the company store, with McParland in tow. Kehoe breaks down the door and steals a suit for Raines, then grabs all the other clothing off the racks and throws it out to the crowd of miners who’ve gathered around. Then he takes an axe to the shelves, douses everything in gasoline, and sets the whole place ablaze. It’s a moment of fierce, revolutionary joy. The company stores were all too real, and the mine bosses of this era exploited them ruthlessly, often clawing back the majority of their workers’ wages by overcharging for basic necessities like food and clothes. But Ritt captures the moment where the workers finally see the house of exploitation for what it is, and destroy it. That moment is the essence of all revolutionary politics. For one night, humanity triumphs over money. After that, the trials and executions feel like an afterthought.
The astute reader may notice that this whole saga is not exactly a “current affair.” Some miners got a crooked trial in 1876—so what?, you might ask. But there’s a reason this story has stuck in people’s minds for so long. The events themselves are specific to the world of the 19th century, but the political forces that made them happen are not.
For one thing, the coal mining industry never ended, and neither did the miners’ labor struggle. It should have ended; coal is the filthiest and least efficient of all the fossil fuels, and even China is now beginning to phase it out in favor of renewables. It’s frankly embarrassing that “burning rocks” is still a real industry. But the two Trump presidencies have seen a concerted push to keep coal around, aided and abetted by Democrats like West Virginia’s Joe Manchin. Lately, Trump and his flunkies have taken to using the absurd phrase “Beautiful Clean Coal” in all their propaganda. They've even deployed a cartoon mascot called “Coalie.” Worse, Trump has signed executive orders allowing coal mines to emit more pollution, while cutting health programs for workers with black lung disease. More than 150 years after the Molly Maguires, he and the rest of the financial elite are still sacrificing coal miners’ lives and health for profit. Franklin Gowen would approve.
The Trump government has also embraced another tactic that Gowen and the Pinkertons pioneered: accusing immigrants of being in criminal gangs, with little or no evidence, and punishing them without fair trials. Back then it was the Irish; now it’s mainly Latinos in the crosshairs. Remember Andry Hernandez Romero, the gay hairdresser the Trump administration abducted to El Salvador’s CECOT prison camp? He was accused of being in the Tren de Aragua gang simply because he had a tattoo of a crown. Kilmar Abrego Garcia, another deportee, was labeled a member of MS-13 because he wore a Chicago Bulls hat, and because an anonymous informant said so. None of it is proof of wrongdoing, any more than John Kehoe calling a mine boss a “son of a bitch” all those years ago was proof. But because these people aren’t wealthy, and aren’t white, it doesn’t matter. They can’t afford rights.
It was the same with Sacco and Vanzetti, who were never proven to have committed any crime, but were hanged in 1927 regardless. It was the same with Ethel Rosenberg, who was executed as a spy for the Soviet Union in 1953, despite no solid evidence that she shared in her husband’s espionage. Countless Black defendants across the South in the Jim Crow years, tried and falsely convicted by all-white juries, could tell you about the “rule of law.” So could the Native American activist Leonard Peltier, who spent 50 years in prison for murders he was never proven to have committed, and only got his sentence commuted in 2024, as Joe Biden was shuffling out the door of the White House.
It’s all still happening today. Environmental lawyer Steven Donziger spent more than two years under house arrest thanks to a private prosecution by the oil company Chevron, exactly like the private prosecution Franklin Gowen mounted in 1876. In Atlanta, activists who oppose the “Cop City” law enforcement facility have been slapped with RICO charges designed for Mafia bosses. Time after time, we see that when the interests of big corporations and the state conflict with those of ordinary people, it’s the ordinary people who lose, no matter the facts of the case. In The State and Revolution, Vladimir Lenin famously said that “Freedom in capitalist society always remains about the same as it was in the ancient Greek republics: freedom for the slave-owners.” We might adapt the quote today, and say that law in capitalist society remains the same: law for mine bosses.
The person who really troubles me, though, is John Cox Sanders, and not only because of the long-attenuated genetic connection between us. He’s a perfect example of how easy it is for someone to become an instrument of injustice and death, just by quietly accepting what they’re told by authority figures. He probably wasn’t a particularly bad man. But when he saw that he had been placed on a segregated jury with no Irish people on it, he didn’t speak up. I’ve spent a lot of time scrolling through PDFs of old newspapers, and there’s no record I can find of anything specific he said, during what was obviously a series of rigged and unfair trials. It seems he just meekly did what was expected of him, nodded along, and cast his “guilty” vote. He trusted in the institutions and the rule of law, like a good liberal. When Gowen and McParland were giving their speeches, he didn’t ask the all-important question: is it actually true? And when that question isn’t asked, the consequences are almost always grim.
There’s a line in that old folk song, “Sons of Molly,” that sticks with me, too. It’s part of the chorus, after each of the condemned men announces his guilt or innocence:
But I will die with my head held high
For I fought for the men below
The men who slave and sweat and die
Down in the black hell-hole.
This is exactly what John Cox Sanders could never say. He didn’t fight for anyone, let alone the miners, and his memory will always be a shameful one because of it. But if you tweak the gendered language a little, it’s the best epitaph I can think of: For I fought for the ones below. I wouldn’t mind having that on my own tombstone, when the day comes. We should all aspire to be the kinds of people who can say it truthfully: that we didn’t just sit quietly in the jury box and let the rich and powerful do whatever they want. That in the long war between the classes, we struck a blow back. That when we had the chance, we burned the company store to the ground. Only then will we be able to hold our heads high, in a better world.


