Meanwhile, Zohran Is Just Getting Things Done

As Trump creates economic havoc and commits war crimes, the socialist mayor of New York City demonstrates what serious, responsible government looks like.

“I’ve thought a lot about scaffolding,” New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani says in a new video posted on social media, announcing regulatory changes aimed at reducing the length of time that scaffolding overstays its welcome over city sidewalks. So-called “sidewalk sheds” are everywhere in New York, many hanging around for years, long after the construction work is done. Mamdani’s video explains how these sheds unnecessarily blight the city and inconvenience people, and lays out his proposed fixes (reducing size requirements for the structures, imposing new fines for sheds left up for too long, changing the building inspection schedule).

The scaffolding initiative is representative of the kind of action that has so far characterized Mamdani’s first 100 days in office: not transformative, not obviously “socialist,” but “material” and visible, improving people’s lives in a small, tangible way. For instance, he has been aggressively filling potholes. The city’s Department of Transportation filled 3,946 potholes in March, the most in a single month in over half a decade. (He poured concrete into the 100,000th pothole of the year himself, hard hat and all.) The New York Times, reviewing his record, notes that:

“Mr. Mamdani has hustled up a litany of quick accomplishments. He has reignited projects to improve bus speeds; built a City Hall rest stop for delivery workers; opened a long-delayed new infirmary for Rikers Island detainees; secured state money to fund an incremental expansion of free preschool; and wielded the powers of his office to go after both abusive employers and bad landlords.”

Mamdani’s actions include making it easier to cancel subscriptions, introducing a website featuring an easy-to-use map of childcare options, providing millions in funding for new public bathrooms, expanding paid time off and issuing warnings to businesses to ensure compliance, upgrading storm drains and catch basins, building new EV charging stations and suing employers who rip off workers. The mayor’s office has released a much longer list of other victories.

The New York Times, while conceding this “litany of quick accomplishments,” notes that he has made “no discernible progress” toward eliminating the police department’s controversial “Strategic Response Group” and has reversed course on some pledges, like his previous promise to relinquish mayoral control over public schools. They also suggest that, while Mamdani may be doing plenty of small, practical things that improve people’s lives, he’s not doing socialism. The Times writes that “As New York’s first modern mayor to wholly embrace democratic socialism, Mr. Mamdani has little actual power to impose that ideology on city government,” and say he is “prioritizing brass tacks projects over ideological ones.” The narrative is that while Mamdani may be a good mayor, he’s a good mayor because he’s setting aside his socialism and focusing on simply governing well.

But this is wrong. Socialism is not just about bringing the means of production into state ownership, but about adhering to a set of egalitarian principles that emphasize solidarity, erode class distinctions, and build the public sector and public assets, making our country work for everyone and not for the profits of large corporations. Fixing potholes may not be “socialist,” but Mamdani’s aggressive effort to escalate small infrastructure fixes is part of a much broader plan to restore faith in the public sector’s ability to get things done. Mamdani is fighting against decades of neoliberal ideology that told people, in Ronald Reagan’s words, that the “scariest words in the English language are ‘I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.’” Mamdani is trying to demonstrate that the opposite is true: that when you’re struggling, the exact thing you want is for a city worker to show up and help, because they’re good at their jobs, they care about you, and they don’t send you a fat bill.

The Mamdani administration, like his campaign, deploys whimsical humor. He is having Cardi B judge a contest to come up with a jingle for his new free childcare program. He had city residents vote in a “Mayoral Madness” bracket on which infrastructure fix he should perform himself. A press conference about street safety opened with jokes about New York City’s famous “pizza rat.” Another press conference, announcing a legal settlement with the HungryPanda delivery platform for ripping off restaurants, was held in front of the red panda exhibit at the Prospect Park Zoo. (Mamdani: “This hungry red panda at the Prospect Park Zoo? Adorable. The HungryPanda delivery app scamming hundreds of small businesses? Not adorable.”)

But there is a serious purpose behind all this. Mamdani realized early on that stunts are valuable if they are done to draw attention to something that otherwise wouldn’t get attention. The jingle contest is a way of publicizing a social democratic program. The panda photo op is about getting eyes on a legal settlement against a predatory corporation. Even the fun stuff is very carefully engineered to make a point, and it’s all part of Mamdani’s overall mission to restore faith in the public sector and pave the way for the big, transformative changes that he aims at long term. You can see this as the “compromise” of a radical who has run into reality, but as a socialist (and the author of a book literally called Why You Should Be a Socialist) I think Mamdani is extremely smart to focus early on on delivering small things that people can see and feel. This was the approach taken by the “sewer socialists” in the early 20th century, and by Bernie Sanders when he was mayor of Burlington, Vermont in the 1980s, and it resulted in popular mayoral administrations that served as living disproof of propaganda about socialist politicians bringing “disaster” and “ruin.”

Mamdani needs to be given some time before we judge him on the major campaign promises about police reform, free buses, cheaper housing, etc. This stuff doesn’t happen overnight. What he is doing right now is what he should be doing, which is overcoming the presumption that a young democratic socialist cannot handle the nuts and bolts of day-to-day governance. If people have much more positive experiences with city government under Mamdani, if they notice their potholes getting filled, their snow being shoveled, and their landlords being held accountable for violations of the law, Mamdani will have the public support necessary to push for big things. He needs to ensure, first and foremost, that the quality of life in the city is getting better in ways that are impossible for even the New York Post to ignore. As Jacobin’s Liza Featherstone writes of this “blitz of conspicuous municipal competence”: “Clean, attractive streetscapes with fewer rats and working sewers could strengthen his case for a robust, well-funded government and give him credibility as a steward of our tax dollars, including a future infusion of new public resources obtained by taxing the rich.”

So far it seems to be working, although Mamdani is unfortunately working with a sizable budget deficit left over from the previous administration that is forcing him to get creative. The murder and shooting rate is even at its lowest point in recorded history for the first three months of the year, though it’s hard to think how Mamdani could have caused that except by spreading good vibes and civic pride. There will always be critics who say that he has “zero accomplishments except fanning Jew-hate,” but if New Yorkers notice that after they attend one of Mamdani’s “rental ripoff hearings,” there start to be changes in their building, they may start thinking to themselves that democratic socialism seems like it might be worth believing in.

Amid all the bleak news in this country right now, the Mamdani mayoralty is giving me a lot of hope. As Trump commits war crime after war crime, plunging the economy into chaos and fixing nothing, Mamdani is in New York taking seriously the job of governing, and showing what it would look like if we had a functional country where the state served the people. I do not know how much democratic socialism he will achieve over the course of his tenure, but if he can show that electing democratic socialist mayors is the way to get our infrastructure fixed, while Washington is proving that electing MAGA leaders is an international catastrophe, Mamdani’s tenure will be very good for the left.

 

More In: Politics

Cover of latest issue of print magazine

Announcing Our Newest Issue

Featuring

A dive into the banal horror of Jimmy Fallon, the surprising politics of Texas’s original cowboys, and the hidden history behind a 19th-century coal mining murder spree. Beyond breathtaking cover art by Myriam Wares, you’ll discover the beauty of monster-hunting comic Bitter Root, and perhaps walk away with a newfound respect for ska music. We also look at the dark underbelly of lolcow culture, explore a long-lost socialist village in India, and learn how Bernie Sanders conquered Burlington. Speaking of Vermont, we also sit down with Ben & Jerry’s co-founder Ben Cohen to hear why he pivoted from making ice cream to trying to stop the U.S. war machine. Oh, and you’ll find an op-ed on the attention crisis from none other than Adam McKay: the Academy Award-winning filmmaker behind The Big Short, Vice, and Don’t Look Up. This is one magazine you don't want to miss.

The Latest From Current Affairs